top of page

Hot Take of the Week: Lewandowski or Maxi, who will have the better MLS legacy?

Writer: Brian Maurer
Brian Maurer
1 day ago
2 min read

By Brian Maurer | @BAMaurerMedia


Hot Take

Charlotte FC gets set to take on the Chicago Fire in a best-of-three Round 1 matchup in the MLS Cup Playoffs. Both teams have made massive signings this summer. The Fire brought in legendary striker Robert Lewandowski, who scored his first MLS goal against Charlotte. The Crown signed star winger Allan Saint-Maximin. Both players are expected to lead their team's attack and help make deep playoff runs this season.


The expectations for Lewandowski and Saint-Maximin go beyond the 2026 playoffs. Both are expected to leave legacies that help carry their respective clubs into the next era of MLS.


Who will leave the better legacy?


Lewandowski has time working against him. At the 38-years-old, the question how long the Polish legend will want to keep fighting is going to come up every year he is a part of Chicago.


The upside for Lewandowski is that he is an elite goal scorer who already has 13 goal contributions (9g/4a) in his first half season. If he keeps up that rate of production throughout a full year for multiple seasons, he will make a strong argument that he will leave a lasting impact at one of the underrated massive sports markets.


Saint-Maximin, at 29, is still in his prime and has several years left where he should be capable of putting massive pressure on defenders with his on-ball speed and 1v1 dribbling. The French winger has time on his side but doesn't have the same trajectory of goal production rate.


Saint-Maximin's legacy will be a bit more dependent on how well he opens up space and creates opportunities for teammates, which will need to lead to a collectively strong attacking front.


Trophies and consistent deep runs in the postseason will be the final determining factor, which means these new MLS stars' legacy pursuits start this weekend.



Arguments for Robert Lewandowski building the better MLS legacy


  1. Lewandowski still has lots of goals in him, and goals amplify legends more than anything.

  2. He will be the star who helps lead from the front as Chicago opens their new soccer-specific stadium.

  3. The aura that surrounds the Polish legend is enough to carry him through MLS as a massive legend stateside.


Arguments for Allan Saint-Maximin building the better MLS legacy


  1. Saint-Maximin's unique skills on the ball are massively entertaining and will make him stand out in MLS for years to come.

  2. He is in his prime, giving him more time to hit a higher peak and leave a lasting impression on this league.

  3. He has the opportunity to help Charlotte lift the city's first major sports trophy.




bottom of page